As a Filipina with straight, short eyelashes, I have used Latisse, Rodan & Field's eyelash serum, traditional fake eyelashes, and eye lash extensions. I'm very familiar with putting on eye lashes, but I struggle with these. It's the liner. I think it's drying out and it was sent to me this way. I reached out to Moshika when I first tried the liner and have heard from no one. I'm sadly disappointed. I was about to place an order for Judy Lim's Embossed brand eyelashes, but ordered these when I saw the Instagram live. I gave it 3 stars as the lash lengths look good and when I could get the liner to come out, it works.